Minor revision comments

Generally minor revisions can be addressed quickly and often come down to clarifying things for the reviewers: rewording, addressing minor concerns etc and don’t require any more … cm2400 compustar Practical advice for responding to reviewers’ comments 1. Say thanks 2. Summarize the revisions you made 3. Make your answers easy to see 4. Avoid giving yes or no answers 5. Whenever … butler inclined platform lift Jul 30, 2015 · The major and minor revisions distinction is arbitrary in any case and often meaningless. I have seen some reviewers write several pages of comments and tick 'minor revisions' while others write a one-line review with 'major revisions' ticked. Of course, the decision conveyed to the author will be an amalgam of these comments and opinions along ... gua sha for breast enlargement In this case, "no additional reviews required" would mean that the journal editors will themselves check whether the minor revisions suggested were made satisfactorily and the manuscript will not be sent back to the peer reviewers. This will save time and allow the final decision to be communicated to you quickly.Oct 20, 2014 · The way we are going to implement major/minor changes in Windchill, is with view versions. When CADdocuments are raised in revision, the Design-vv of the WTPart is raised as well (in the beginning of the process). But the ERP-vv will only be raised when the change is considered as a major (at the end of the process). gorm preload performanceBy going to the item edit menu. Select the item for which you want the check the comment. Click on the three dots (…) ellipses menu, then click on the Edit menu. Step 1: Track item history comment details in the SharePoint Online list. Step 2: Now, in the comments section - you can add comments about the changes you do in the list items so ... lebenslauf A minor change is a change that not has to be trackable in the future. We don't want to know on which machines these changed parts were used. This in contrast with major changes. For major changes, we want to be able to decide where these components are used, and want to be able in the future to track where they were used.So, based on when all are back and available for the final check, the status will change and the manuscript move to the final review stage. Anyway, as yours was a minor revision, you probably don’t have much need to worry, which actually may be just the reason you wish to hear the decision on your paper. :) So, you could wait a week or so.A review by the editor for alignment with aims and scope of the journal. Reviews conducted by two to three expert reviewers with knowledge in the content area and skills in evaluating scholarly writing. An associate editor reviews the manuscript and the reviews and recommendations of the reviewers.comments have been addressed with either new analysis or necessary discussions. Response: Thank you very much. Some minor revisions for the authors to ...The reason is that reviewer#2 refers back to the same old comments that he gave at the major revision stage (He just copied and pasted alll the comments mentioned in the major revision stage ... 超Minor revisionからのUnder review. 論文投稿記. Elsevier系列の雑誌に投稿していた論文の1st decisionが返ってきた。. レビュワーは2人で、どちらの方も単語や体裁上の細かいミスの指摘だけで、. 「掲載するべき」とacceptを推奨するコメントまで付いていた。. こんな ...The revised version of your manuscript xxx has been reviewed by our referees. Referee A is now satisfied with your paper, while Referee B is more or less satisfied but … guitar scales and modes pdf Accept, Reject and Minor Revisions. ... Thanks all for useful comments. I got Major revision and a bit confused how to respond properly to all theses questions. I got some questions that really not useful and not following the main goal of my manuscript. As the Major Revision was suggested I can easily delete some data and add some new data.Moderate revision. 审稿决定"Moderate revision"意味着你的论文很有可能被录用,但需要做出额外的修改,以满足审稿人的意见。 这些修改通常比"Minor revision"需要更多的时间,通常会给你两到四周的时间把修改过的文章修回给投稿期刊,但同样会因为期刊而异。Feb 18, 2020 · Comments: You seem to have received comments from two reviewers, one for a minor revision and the other for a major revision. So, there is a conflict between the two reviewers regarding the number and kind of changes to be made in the article. Also, according to you, the major revision comments do not all seem to be valid or well-informed. Keep to the facts. Stay polite, but keep emotion out of it. If the reviewers comment is not well founded in fact, it should be quite easy to give a successful response. If you think the … celebrity death pics reddit Oct 06, 2021 · Answer: The editorial board of the journal can take a call on whether the revised manuscript needs to be sent back to the peer reviewers for approval after minor revision. In this case, "no additional reviews required" would mean that the journal editors will themselves check whether the minor revisions suggested were made satisfactorily and ... 2. Plosone. Liou and Peng (2009) More revision oriented comments than non-revision-oriented comments after training. 3. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher … pbot guest parking permits 6 Oct 2021 ... In this case, "no additional reviews required" would mean that the journal editors will themselves check whether the minor revisions ...Moderate revision. 审稿决定“Moderate revision“意味着你的论文很有可能被录用,但需要做出额外的修改,以满足审稿人的意见。 这些修改通常比“Minor revision”需要更多的时间,通常会给你两到四周的时间把修改过的文章修回给投稿期刊,但同样会因为期刊而异。 edmond psychiatric associates patient portal comments have been addressed with either new analysis or necessary discussions. Response: Thank you very much. Some minor revisions for the authors to ...... the five journals can be Minor Revision, Major Revision, Accept or Reject. ... Confidential comments for the Editor: please give your reasons for your ...Examples of minor revision in a sentence, how to use it. 19 examples: It is concluded that only some minor revision of the model with regard to… akron east high school athletics Comments from the reviewers: Reviewer: 1 Recommendation: Comments: I would like to thank the authors for addressing my initial comments. Following the revision to the article, some of my additional comments relate to some of the amendments made, and the authors may therefore wish to discuss these particular suggestions with the editor.The 'Minor Revision' offers the option to control smaller changes without the creation of a new version when a part moves from one production state to another. Both revisions are created in the same way, but they are different in their interpretation. If the change affects the form, function, or fit of the part, it is considered a Major Revision.Recommendation: Accept with minor revision. General comment This paper extends the numerical modelling study of the effects of vertical wind shear on the dynamics and thermodynamics of tropical cyclones by the same authors (Riemer et al., 2010). The idea of analyzing additional numerical experiments to Aug 08, 2016 · Within a short period of time after submission, the status message showed ‘accept pending minor revisions.’ The only comment I received was: "Please check your paper for English language editing, and ensure that you follow the Editorial Formatting Comments listed in this letter. Congratulations." 15 ene 2019 ... The next immediate step after peer review, if the authors are lucky enough, is to revise the manuscript according to editors' and reviewers' ...minor revision means a change to the permit conditions, including any decrease or increase in staffing requirements or monitoring frequencies, correction of minor errors or typographical mistakes, transfer of a permit to a new owner, extension of compliance dates or construction schedules, deletion of outfalls or discharge points, incorporation … horse retirement farms nj Once the reviews have been received by the editor, a decision is made ... Minor essential revisions should be numbered as above, but with a prefix of 2. c4 16 error in samsung ac Aug 17, 2010 · Minor is incremented when some minor functionality has been added, minor functionality depends on the project. Usually means a serious of bug fixes or when existing functionality has been changed. Build is the build number token from our CI server. This allows us to know what build was used to create the release. Sometimes from reviewer's comments it seems a minor revision because few reviewers are very judicious in economy of words and include a deep thought. The reviewer's comments of just 2-3 lines may ... I think one important practical difference between minor and major revisions is the revising time granted to the authors. Typically, editors would be more lenient on the revision time frame if they see a major revision recommendation from the reviewer. 2. level 1. · 6 mo. ago. oklahoma arrests invaluable comments. We have carefully addressed all the comments. The corresponding changes and refinements made in the revised paper are summarized in our response below. Reviewer #2: This paper has a potential to be accepted, but some important points have to be clarified or fixed before we can proceed and a positive action can be taken. bell internet speed Much more problematic, in my experience, are corrections that, although still considered 'minor', involve re-thinking and re-writing. Nobody warns you that you'll need to re-gather your energy and brainpower to tackle them. That, for me, turned into a struggle for which I was completely unprepared. Let's be clear: getting through your ...Editors are most likely to write back to you after initial review and recommend either ‘minor revisions’ or ‘major revisions’ to your paper. The big difference between these two decisions in our experience is whether, or not, your paper will be returned to the peer reviewers for further comments once you have made changes to your work.Mar 06, 2019 · Corrections of that nature can legitimately be considered ‘minor’. But corrections of that kind are only a small part of the story. Much more problematic, in my experience, are corrections that, although still considered ‘minor’, involve re-thinking and re-writing. Minor versions are off by default in a custom list and need to be enabled Versioning can be disabled in a custom list if need be. By default, it captures the last 50 major versions in a custom list. The maximum you can capture would be 50,000. Here is how to alter versioning settings in a custom list: Gear Icon > List Settings unicorn candidate reddit Comment [C6]: Include everything the reviewers write, even if you don't need to reply to it. Comment [C7]: Include line numbers wherever applicable . Comment [C8]: In addition to line numbers, the quoted text helps (the lines will shift if the tracked changes to the manuscript are acc epted) Sample Response to Revision RequestSometimes from reviewer's comments it seems a minor revision because few reviewers are very judicious in economy of words and include a deep thought. The reviewer's comments of just 2-3 lines may ... revised manuscript. One more general remark: What about calling Section 12 ‘Summary and Conclusions’ and Section 13 ‘Future work’ in order to better reflect their content. Reply: As … harbour isle condos for sale by owner Most people who attend are also scammers themselves. They need a "talk at a conference" or better even a "keynote speaker" entry for their resume and this is their only chance (you can usually buy the keynote speaker slot, which in of itself is ridiculous). Their "research" is also mostly shit. And they're spread out over multiple fields, so ...A minor change is a change that not has to be trackable in the future. We don't want to know on which machines these changed parts were used. This in contrast with major changes. For major changes, we want to be able to decide where these components are used, and want to be able in the future to track where they were used. del morino for sale Update on EAD: Minor revisions and call for comments on upcoming major revision2015. gada 26. maijs ... a statement thanking the editor for considering the revised version. If the revisions were pretty straightforward, the cover letter is short.It’s unusual to have a rejection after minor revisions. Unless you were antagonistic in your approach to the reviewers, I would suspect the possibility of an administrative error. It even …Jun 22, 2016 · I often experience reviews labelled as “major revisions” which are actually minor revisions once you read the actual reviewers’ comments. Seems like there’s been a shift toward caustiously cautious framing of reviews by editors over the last decades (I also got a “minor revisions” which was merely rewording one sentence and fixing ... Accept after Minor Revisions: The paper is in principle accepted after revision based on the reviewer's comments. Authors are given five days for minor ... queensland department of transport Minor revisions and major revisions are the two most common editorial decisions after peer review. A decision of minor revisions means your work will likely not be going back to the original peer reviewers for another round of comments. This is actually a policy for many journals. Do the revisions and resubmit.Jan 08, 2021 · So, based on when all are back and available for the final check, the status will change and the manuscript move to the final review stage. Anyway, as yours was a minor revision, you probably don’t have much need to worry, which actually may be just the reason you wish to hear the decision on your paper. :) So, you could wait a week or so. Considerations for Minor Revisions ... This decision also means that from the journal's perspective one of their editorial board members or the editor will now ...15 feb 2022 ... Minor revisions - Manuscript can be accepted ... reviewers' reports and comments posted by Associate Editor in the Editor tab will be ...comments and recommendations for improvement. ... Ask for minor revision for likely acceptance. – Request major revision for another review process. michelin crossclimate 2 vs defender reddit Sometimes from reviewer's comments it seems a minor revision because few reviewers are very judicious in economy of words and include a deep thought. The reviewer's comments of just 2-3 lines may ... cummins def tank heater Major.Minor.Patch.Revision format #11 Closed jerone opened this issue on Mar 22, 2018 · 4 comments jerone commented on Mar 22, 2018 • edited bug gabrielrobert mentioned this issue on Mar 25, 2018 Revision parsing #13 Merged xavtool will generate a revision-based version for UWP. It will ignore the last sequence and just put '0' for all versions.Once you manuscript has come back from reviewers you may be given the opportunity to revise it in accordance with the reviewer comments.For a minor revision, the editor may decide to send the revised manuscript to the peer reviewer for a final check or review the manuscript themselves if the changes were indeed minor. Based on this, it may take about two-three weeks for this round of … aquarius ring wearing finger Concise review with suggestions for a few minor revisions ... In their response to my previous comments, the authors have clarified that only the data from ...A minor change is a change that not has to be trackable in the future. We don't want to know on which machines these changed parts were used. This in contrast with major changes. For major changes, we want to be able to decide where these components are used, and want to be able in the future to track where they were used. brian burkheiser wifeMinor Revisions indicates a solid manuscript that could be improved with ... The decision, along with the reviewers' comments, are shared with the authors.Apr 05, 2021 · Generally minor revisions can be addressed quickly and often come down to clarifying things for the reviewers: rewording, addressing minor concerns etc and don’t require any more experiments or analysis. You stand a really good chance of getting the paper published if you’ve been given a minor revisions result. Accept the paper with no revisions. best kitchen faucets 2021 If your work obtains the verdict "accept with minor revisions," there is a good probability it will be accepted if you answer the criticisms thoroughly. Sometimes the editor or reviewers suggest changes that would improve the manuscript. In this case, you should consider their suggestions and send back your revised document.Reviewer Comments to Author(s): Reviewer #1 (Jillon Vander Wal, PhD): Overall, this is a clear, concise, and well-written manuscript. The introduction is relevant and theory based. Sufficient information about the previous study findings is presented for readers to follow the present study rationale and procedures. riverside caravan park site map All the changes are marked in yellow in the revised manuscript for your comments. 2). As described in 3.1 "The photoreduction of Cr (VI) and photodegradation of cationic dyes was performed at neutral pH = 7, 0.1M NaOH or 0.1M HCL (note: should be HCl) was used to adjust the pH of the desired solution."Conclusion: Minor revision Classification: Grade A (Excellent) Language Evaluation: Grade A: priority publishing Comments to authors: The manuscript is well written and after some minor revision could be suitable for publication. First of all, the references should be presented according to journal guidelines.In this case, "no additional reviews required" would mean that the journal editors will themselves check whether the minor revisions suggested were made satisfactorily and the manuscript will not be sent back to the peer reviewers. This will save time and allow the final decision to be communicated to you quickly. list of colleges not requiring covid vaccine for fall 2022 The ‘Minor Revision’ offers the option to control smaller changes without the creation of a new version when a part moves from one production state to another. Both revisions are created in the same way, but they are different in their interpretation. If the change affects the form, function, or fit of the part, it is considered a Major ... What does a ‘revisions required’ editorial decision really mean? Charlesworth Author Services 28/02/2019 00:00:00. How to deal with revise and resubmit to an academic journal . …Oct 06, 2021 · Answer: The editorial board of the journal can take a call on whether the revised manuscript needs to be sent back to the peer reviewers for approval after minor revision. In this case, "no additional reviews required" would mean that the journal editors will themselves check whether the minor revisions suggested were made satisfactorily and ... abandoned places to explore in st louis Comments: You seem to have received comments from two reviewers, one for a minor revision and the other for a major revision. So, there is a conflict between the two reviewers regarding the number and kind of changes to be made in the article. Also, according to you, the major revision comments do not all seem to be valid or well-informed.A minor change is a change that not has to be trackable in the future. We don't want to know on which machines these changed parts were used. This in contrast with major changes. For major changes, we want to be able to decide where these components are used, and want to be able in the future to track where they were used.Examples of minor revision in a sentence, how to use it. 19 examples: It is concluded that only some minor revision of the model with regard to… pike place starbucks By going to the item edit menu. Select the item for which you want the check the comment. Click on the three dots (…) ellipses menu, then click on the Edit menu. Step 1: Track item history comment details in the SharePoint Online list. Step 2: Now, in the comments section - you can add comments about the changes you do in the list items so ... break up chats Define Minor revision. means a change to the permit conditions, including any decrease or increase in staffing requirements or monitoring frequencies, correction of minor errors or typographical mistakes, transfer of a permit to a new owner, extension of compliance dates or construction schedules, deletion of outfalls or discharge points, incorporation of an approved pretreatment program by ... revised manuscript. One more general remark: What about calling Section 12 ‘Summary and Conclusions’ and Section 13 ‘Future work’ in order to better reflect their content. Reply: As …Common Errors That Lead to Rejection (Part 3) In part 1 and part 2, we focused on the common reasons for revision and rejection by journals. Here we focus on how to deal with …Solution 2 I don't know what "awaiting reviewer invitation" means. But usually, the paper with minor revision will be sent directly back to the same reviewers for the final decision. They need to check whether you revise according to their reviews. 2,258 Related videos on Youtube Authors: Revised Manuscript Submission, Editorial ManagerMinor changes will usually be assessed directly by the editor If significant revisions were requested, the editor will usually return the manuscript to the original reviewers (unless they opted out of this) Rarely, the editor may invite comments from a new reviewer – the editor should explain why this fresh review is sought. atco australia What used to be called “Minor Revisions” is now called “Reject (With Invited Resubmission)” with a shorter timeline. And Accept is still Accept. Here’s the explanation. A flat-out rejection — “Please don’t send us this paper again” — hasn’t changed. (I’ve pointed out before, that it takes some experience to know when a paper is actually rejected .)comments and recommendations for improvement. ... Ask for minor revision for likely acceptance. – Request major revision for another review process. deep lake recreational park for sale : Yes, the corresponding author emailed the editor to consider a revision. But, the editor did not consider it. Then again asked the cause of rejection, because it seems the reviewer’s comments...Mar 20, 2017 · A major revision goes back to reviewers, while the minor revision goes to the (associate) editor for a decision. The vast majority of minor revisions are ultimately accepted for publication, while many more major revisions are later found unacceptable and rejected. Minor Revision I've more or less got this spreadsheet where I need it to be but was hoping to automate one last function. I've got it down to where my employees only need to enter in data …comments and recommendations for improvement. On the basis of the reviewer's report, the editor will make one of the following decisions on your paper. ... - Ask for minor revision for likely acceptance - Request major revision for another review process - Reject outright Responsibility of the reviewer The reviewer must provide to the ...All the changes are marked in yellow in the revised manuscript for your comments. 2). As described in 3.1 "The photoreduction of Cr (VI) and photodegradation of cationic dyes was performed at neutral pH = 7, 0.1M NaOH or 0.1M HCL (note: should be HCl) was used to adjust the pH of the desired solution."Passed viva with minor revisions—totally overwhelmed Post-PhD UK based. Yesterday was my viva. It went so well—was fun, interesting, no extremely hard questions or glaring issues. Everything ran smoothly and my examiners were kind and engaging. It honestly couldn’t have gone better as far as the defense goes. Passed with minor revisions. va disability for appendectomy Add a comment 6 Answers Sorted by: 15 Minor revision usually implies that the reviewers (and the editor) think that authors can correct the paper in a way that will address all of the concerns, and the reviewers not need to see the paper again before publication.Solution 2. Yes, characterizing revisions as "minor" strongly suggests that if you make those revisions the paper will be accepted. Editors may prefer not to explicitly say that the paper is "accepted with minor revisions", because authors may make "minor revisions" that don't correct the problems, and then feel that they've been promised ...Sometimes from reviewer's comments it seems a minor revision because few reviewers are very judicious in economy of words and include a deep thought. The reviewer's comments of just 2-3 lines may ...15 ene 2019 ... The next immediate step after peer review, if the authors are lucky enough, is to revise the manuscript according to editors' and reviewers' ... west palm beach house rentals Passed viva with minor revisions—totally overwhelmed Post-PhD UK based. Yesterday was my viva. It went so well—was fun, interesting, no extremely hard questions or glaring issues. Everything ran smoothly and my examiners were kind and engaging. It honestly couldn’t have gone better as far as the defense goes. Passed with minor revisions.Sample 1. Minor Revisions as defined in Rule 62-620.200, F.A.C. to wastewater permits for delegated domestic wastewater facilities. Sample 1. Minor Revisions. Minor revisions to an …Accept/Minor Revision/Major Revision/Reject in the questionnaire. Give specific feedback that ... Avoid vague comments; offer concrete suggestions to. usafa graduation 2022 This is why I regard the “revisions required” judgment as “minor revisions required.” In practice, this means that I will not send out your revision again and ... american bully for sale georgia 15 feb 2022 ... Minor revisions - Manuscript can be accepted ... reviewers' reports and comments posted by Associate Editor in the Editor tab will be ...Reviewer A's Comments to Authors: ... should state the exact number of patients who bled post EMR (both major and minor bleeding). ankha conda General Comments. The paper 'An overview of the MILAGRO 2006 campaign: Mexico City emissions and their transport and transformation' by L.T. Molina, ...22 jul 2022 ... B-minor revisions required (no further formal external peer-review round required, reviewer will not see the revision, editor makes decision); C ...15 ene 2019 ... The next immediate step after peer review, if the authors are lucky enough, is to revise the manuscript according to editors' and reviewers' ...minor revision means a change to the permit conditions, including any decrease or increase in staffing requirements or monitoring frequencies, correction of minor errors or typographical mistakes, transfer of a permit to a new owner, extension of compliance dates or construction schedules, deletion of outfalls or discharge points, incorporation … new orleans apartments